|
|
|
2010 2011 BMW 5 Series Forum F10 Drove a 528 vs 535 - Preferred the 528 |
|
Post Reply |
|
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
05-05-2011, 01:41 PM | #45 | |
Major General
6645
Rep 6,726
Posts |
Quote:
My budget was limited when I bought the car, and I was looking at 528's vs. the 535. Now, I am a torque junkie. I love the effortless power and having to not shift to move off. But part of me also likes to hear the engine wind up the RPM scale. Where I live, in the DC metro area, there is so little room to use the potential of the 535 that it's sad. I think I drive around all day hardly ever cracking 2,500 RPM because it's frustrating to do so then slam on the brakes to avoid hitting the cars stopped at the next stoplight. The 528 feels decently fast, but it feels like you have to work harder at it. The car never sounds strained, it sounds pretty good actually, but you do have to rev it a little more. The 535 is more effortless....press and go. All comes down to what you want and how you drive. I am sure there are people on a budget who don't mind hearing that straight six wind out and would rather spend the $$ on options instead of engine and fuel costs. in the end, I ended up with a 535 but as I said...I'm a torque junkie. |
|
Appreciate
0
|
05-05-2011, 01:56 PM | #46 |
Major
33
Rep 1,134
Posts |
I have driven all three models extensively on the autobahn for many miles in all sorts of road characteristics. Anyone saying that the differences are slight between the 528 and 535 have not truly driven these vehicles comparatively.
529 to 535 to 550 is like apples to oranges to bananas, nothing alike. If you do not share in this opinion I would suggest getting past reading the same tired reviews and/or around the corner demo's with some bloke sitting next to you.
__________________
2014 550i M-sport
|
Appreciate
0
|
05-05-2011, 03:15 PM | #47 |
Private First Class
2
Rep 100
Posts |
Well, I didn't say there was no difference between the two cars. What I said was that I preferred the 528i to the 535i based on the 2 test drives. Never drove the 550 so I don't know about it. Would I take a 535i for the same price as the 528i? Of course. It's a higher value package. But, to me, the extra power isn't worth the extra money because I really couldn't feel much difference in acceleration and handling was the same. 7 seconds to 60 mph is plenty fast for a 4 door sedan. Getting there in 6 seconds instead just doesn't matter to me that much. When I want power I drive my Corvette.
__________________
2017 540ix Dark Graphite Metallic/Ivory/Black Dakota
Previous 2014 535ix Imperial Blue/Oyster, Comfort Seats 2011 528i Cashmere Silver/Black Dakota 2001 530i Sport (deceased) Last edited by BobRBob; 05-05-2011 at 06:12 PM.. |
Appreciate
0
|
05-05-2011, 03:34 PM | #48 |
Major
33
Rep 1,134
Posts |
I understand.
I do want to point out, this focus on 0-60mph, when I look for performance I look for it starting at 60mph minimum. I want to know, scratch that, I want to FEEL the car pull me from 80mph to 140mph. In this regard, you can feel the difference between a 528 and 535.
__________________
2014 550i M-sport
|
Appreciate
0
|
05-05-2011, 03:51 PM | #49 |
Private
1
Rep 59
Posts |
All three models 528, 535, and 550 have their pros and cons, and they will suit folks with varying needs. For me, it was the 535 that suits me. For some reason, at least here in Chicago, and based on postings in the forums, it certainly seems like there are a whole lot more 535's than 528's out there.
|
Appreciate
0
|
05-05-2011, 04:01 PM | #50 |
Colonel
716
Rep 2,003
Posts |
A 535 is a 528 with a turbo charger.. hopefully there is a difference.
The problem is, ppl who don't know much about cars, just assume a 535>528 inherently, without appreciating in this instance there is a very distinct and important difference between the two. For the 550/535 comparison one could use the same broad stroke, as the difference between the two are in both displacement/cylinders and turbos. Like a 550i is much 'more' of a 535i, with 2 more cylinders (diff, configuration) and 2 turbos to the one (is it even 'larger'?) With the new I4 turbo, the 'family' of engines will become logical once more.. the I6 NA will go off in to the sunset and away from the "more is always better" crowd. |
Appreciate
0
|
05-05-2011, 04:02 PM | #51 | |
Captain
36
Rep 852
Posts |
I can "afford" it too, but just because you can afford something doesn't mean you will feel comfortable getting it ( you said yourself "could probably stretch to a loaded M3 as well" which tells me you really can't truly afford it) ... if you have couple millions in your bank account then yes, you can REALLY afford it, but most people don't... most people on this board got many other payments to take care off such as houses, insurances, kids, wifes, etc, etc not just car payment... and bottom line is, if you ask 100 people if money is no issue, 95 would pick 550 over 528
Quote:
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
05-05-2011, 05:01 PM | #52 |
Registered
0
Rep 3
Posts |
I always find it funny when people bring up the issue of affordability when comparing 528 to 535. Lets get real. a 5-10k difference on a 60k car isn't huge, especially on a 3 year lease.
Yes, for many, its a major consideration when taking into account budgets, income, etc. But when broken down by monthly payment on a lease, the people driving 535s shouldn't feel any sort of superiority over those driving 528s. Now, I had a 2007 M5 and currently have a 2011 M3 Vert and I can "afford" any of the F10s. I test drove all three and can honestly say I prefer the 528 over the 535 for many of the same reasons the OP stated. I'm getting older and honestly don't need the extra speed for my family car - especially when I already have an M3 for "sporty" driving. In the end, it's all about what you're looking for. I'm not a torque guy and hate turbo so I prefer the 528. I think the ones who think the 528 guys are justifying their purchase because they can't afford it are probably the same guys who feel superior because they drive a car that is 10k more. |
Appreciate
0
|
05-05-2011, 08:32 PM | #53 | |
Reader
31
Rep 126
Posts |
528 Enthusiasm
Quote:
I can understand some of your enthusiasm for a normally-aspirated six, which is the icon of BMW engines. However, I would point out: - the front brakes on the 528i (13.0 in diameter) are smaller than on 535i (13.7 in.) - standard tire for 528i is 225/55-17, vs. more performance oriented 245/45-18 on 535i - in Canada, Dynamic Handling is not even available as an option on the 528i (although it is in USA) The above would suggest that the 528i is NOT viewed by BMW as the 'sporty' version of F10. It simply has reduced equipment levels to arrive at a lower price point. The notion of a 'campaign' for NA engines flies in the face of reality. BMW is committed to turbo technology, as a means of achieving high power and torque while reducing fuel consumption and emissions. That is made absolutely clear by the transition of the M5 to turbo-V8 and M3 to turbo-I6. The direction is set. If you are so enthusiastic about lightness and agility, perhaps you could forget XDrive and focus on a RWD 528i plus a set of winter tires. AWD is superfluous in Toronto ~98% of the time, despite being pushed by BMW, M-B and Audi in the Canadian market. |
|
Appreciate
0
|
05-05-2011, 11:05 PM | #54 | |
Private First Class
5
Rep 100
Posts |
Quote:
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
05-06-2011, 02:50 AM | #55 |
Captain
197
Rep 800
Posts |
I think one main thing to point out here is that the OP test drove a 528i with the "Sport Auto". This is a HUGE difference. I drove a 528i with the standard auto and it was a dog, completely underwhelming and immediately dissapointed. I then test drove a 535i with sport auto and although the immediate power was there it felt like I was driving a large car, more like a cruiser, a 7 series or large Lexus.
Then today I got the chance to drive the 528i with "sport Auto" and put it in "sport" and "sport+" modes and OMG what a difference, it was actually fun to drive and I could hear the exhaust and I didnt feel like I was driving a large cruiser. With the money I save, I can now get the M sport package on the 528i. The only downside (for me) is that exhaust being on one side, but again thats minor and can be modded at some point. |
Appreciate
0
|
05-06-2011, 06:53 AM | #56 | |
Private First Class
4
Rep 164
Posts
Drives: Serpent S966
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: INA
|
Quote:
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
05-06-2011, 09:26 AM | #57 |
Private First Class
5
Rep 100
Posts |
|
Appreciate
0
|
05-06-2011, 10:39 AM | #58 |
Private First Class
2
Rep 100
Posts |
Ah, c'mon guys. Horrible rims? Wtf? The 328 wheels look fine to me.
__________________
2017 540ix Dark Graphite Metallic/Ivory/Black Dakota
Previous 2014 535ix Imperial Blue/Oyster, Comfort Seats 2011 528i Cashmere Silver/Black Dakota 2001 530i Sport (deceased) Last edited by BobRBob; 05-06-2011 at 01:49 PM.. |
Appreciate
0
|
05-07-2011, 12:01 AM | #59 |
Colonel
160
Rep 2,248
Posts |
I faced a similar choice between a 328i and a 335i three years ago, but with an extra wrinkle. I wanted a stick. It was available in both models, but I felt that I would be constantly confronted, on every upshift and many downshifts, with turbo lag in the 335i. I felt that the 335i was better suited to an automatic than to a stick. I also like the linear power development of the normally aspirated engine. I might have enjoyed the extra power from time to time, but most of the time a little anticipation in driving makes up for almost any lack of power. If I'd wanted an automatic, I would have chosen the turbo, if only because it has a better transmission. But as it is I've been very happy with the 328i and anticipate keeping it for a while after BMW's best feature has been retired for good.
|
Appreciate
0
|
05-07-2011, 12:12 AM | #60 |
Captain
197
Rep 800
Posts |
|
Appreciate
0
|
05-07-2011, 05:48 PM | #61 | |
Private
8
Rep 90
Posts |
Your reasons are exactly why i like 535 better. And xdrive in mine has the proper steering not electronic.
I guess to each their own. Vibrations on the steering wheel would bother the heck out of me. I also rather prefer the power rather than a pretense of power. But whatever rocks your boat. Just make sure you are not trying to justify your choice of 528 over 535 Quote:
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
05-08-2011, 08:12 AM | #62 |
Private First Class
2
Rep 100
Posts |
FWIW, I don't remember any vibration in the steering during my test drives, subtle or otherwise, and I was checking for steering feel because of all the comments on this forum and others regarding steering and road feel, pulling etc. Also, I didn't notice any throttle issues, hesitations, surging and the like (maybe those issues are 535i only ).
I guess I'll just have to wait and see...
__________________
2017 540ix Dark Graphite Metallic/Ivory/Black Dakota
Previous 2014 535ix Imperial Blue/Oyster, Comfort Seats 2011 528i Cashmere Silver/Black Dakota 2001 530i Sport (deceased) |
Appreciate
0
|
05-21-2011, 02:27 PM | #63 | |
Private First Class
2
Rep 100
Posts |
Quote:
__________________
2017 540ix Dark Graphite Metallic/Ivory/Black Dakota
Previous 2014 535ix Imperial Blue/Oyster, Comfort Seats 2011 528i Cashmere Silver/Black Dakota 2001 530i Sport (deceased) Last edited by BobRBob; 05-21-2011 at 05:59 PM.. |
|
Appreciate
0
|
05-21-2011, 03:09 PM | #64 |
First Lieutenant
217
Rep 372
Posts |
I think I've posted in a couple of threads like this, and I too preferred the 528 over the 535. Loved the shorter gearing, crisper throttle response, better engine sound, and the 528 is no slouch. Didn't think the 535 was really 'all' that much faster.
My biggest complaint though was the complete lack of engine sound in the 535. Inline-6 engines sound great, why would you not want to hear it when you hammer it? Also it didn't seem all that well calibrated to the 8AT. It always wanted to shift whenever you touched the gas, but why? When you've got 300 lb-ft of torque available at pretty much any load RPM just go with whatever gear you're in. I thought the 8AT worked wonderfully with the 528, but not so much with the 535. Test drove an E93/335i with the N55 and 6AT Step and liked it a lot better. You can actually hear the N55 in that vehicle now, top up or down, and it sounds pretty darned good. Also when you put your foot down a bit from an upper gear, it would simply leave it in the taller gear as it should and pulls you away with the torque rather than shifting. Overall I liked the N55/6AT powertrain combo and calibration in the E9x much better than the N55/8AT in the F10. I think BMW still has a bit of work to do on that one.
__________________
2022 G05 X5 40i Phytonic Blue / Ivory
2011 E93 335i Deep Sea Blue / Oyster 2012 E70 X5d Deep Sea Blue / Sand Beige (ret) |
Appreciate
0
|
05-21-2011, 08:18 PM | #65 | |
Second Lieutenant
46
Rep 282
Posts |
Did you test drive the one with sport auto? Sport auto makes all the difference in term of responsiveness on both 528i and 535i.
Quote:
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
05-22-2011, 07:44 AM | #66 |
First Lieutenant
217
Rep 372
Posts |
Both had the standard auto. What difference would the sport auto make?
__________________
2022 G05 X5 40i Phytonic Blue / Ivory
2011 E93 335i Deep Sea Blue / Oyster 2012 E70 X5d Deep Sea Blue / Sand Beige (ret) |
Appreciate
0
|
Post Reply |
Bookmarks |
|
|